A priest at St. Mary’s Catholic Church was named in a lawsuit claiming that the priest sexually battered a parishioner in 2020 and Bishop Richard Stika allowed him to continue to work for the church after receiving the assault report from law enforcement, according to court documents obtained by WVLT News.
In February of 2020, the father of anonymous Jane Doe’s youngest child was killed. Her primary language was Spanish so she reached out to a bilingual assistant at St. Mary’s in order to set up a meeting for emotional support and spiritual guidance.
Father Antony Punnackal was chosen to meet with Doe even though he did not speak 
Spanish. On Feb. 17, 2020, Doe went to St. Mary’s to meet with Punnackal. The bilingual assistant led her to a room with Punnackal and left them alone, according to the documents.
Punnackal locked the doors to the room. He pointed to the Plaintiff’s breasts, asking in pantomime whether she had just given birth and had a baby. Plaintiff’s breasts were indeed full with milk for her infant third child, the same child whose father had just been murdered. Without invitation, Punnackal began fondling Plaintiff’s breasts and buttocks. Plaintiff rebuffed Punnackal but he continued his assault. The locked doors prevented Defendant from leaving. Punnackal eventually unlocked the doors and Plaintiff escaped.
“On information and belief, Punnackal confessed to having sexually assaulted Plaintiff,” court documents state.
Punnackal remained in his role as priest of St. Mary’s Catholic Church, according to the documents.
Punnackal was indicted by a Sevier County Grand Jury in January on one count of sexual battery by an authority figure and one count of sexual battery for the same incident.
“We will not be commenting on Father Punnackal until the matter is resolved in the civil legal system,” Diocese of Knoxville Spokesperson Jim Wogan said. “He has been removed from active ministry.”
